Show Book List

Reviews from Amazon
Amazon.co.uk (0415332877) 2 reviews
A selection of these reviews is given below

Reviews elsewhere on the web:
Guardian Unlimited
H-Net
Curled Up
Telegraph.co.uk
Sue Crawford
theage.com.au

Raimond Gaita

The philosopher's dog

Philosophy can be an obscure subject. In The philosopher's dog Raimond Gaita uses the medium of stories about his dogs and other animals to introduce some deep philosophical ideas, about the status of animals and much more besides. However, it is not a 'Philosophy made simple' sort of a book - some of the philosophy is pretty challenging - and this is where I felt the book falls down. Those who are interested in the doggy anecdotes are likely to be turned off by the philosophising, which increases as the book progresses - there was too much philosophy and not enough dog.

On the other hand, those who's interest lies on the philosophical side are also likely to find the book lacking. For one thing there are no suggestions for further reading and no index. I also felt that Gaita used the structure of the book to introduce some highly dubious claims. He makes the point that some things, such as animal consciousness, aren't things that we can scientifically investigate or even philosophise about: we just know. As the book goes on he adds more things to this category, while I found myself thinking that he was being too dogmatic, and that of course we can speculate about such things.

Amazon.com info
Paperback 224 pages  
ISBN: 0415332877
Salesrank: 2722988
Weight:0.62 lbs
Published: 2004 Routledge
Amazon price $25.95
Marketplace:New from $10.00:Used from $10.00
Buy from Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk info
Paperback 224 pages  
ISBN: 0415332877
Salesrank: 198514
Weight:0.62 lbs
Published: 2004 Routledge
Amazon price £12.34
Marketplace:New from £6.70:Used from £5.70
Buy from Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca info
Paperback 224 pages  
ISBN: 0415332877
Salesrank:
Weight:0.62 lbs
Published: 2004 Routledge
Amazon price CDN$ 16.41
Marketplace:New from CDN$ 16.41
Buy from Amazon.ca

Amazon.co.uk Review
Author of the immensely readable The Philosopher's Dog, Raimond Gaita is Professor of Moral Philosophy at King's College London and Professor of Philosophy at Australian Catholic University. His previous publications include the prize-winning biography of his father, Romulus, My Father and A Common Humanity: Thinking About Love and Truth and Justice.

The Philosopher's Dog is a mixture of storytelling, mostly about Gaita's own, and his father's, relationship with their domestic pets, and philosophical reflections on the stories he tells.

The stories are about animals and their character: about Jack the cockatoo, Orloff, Zac and Gypsy the dogs, about cats, spiders, butterflies, about his father's love and care for bees and his antipathy for insects. All are fascinating and touching stories in themselves. But more than this, Gaita's aim is to bring philosophy and story-telling together without turning the stories into long-winded philosophical examples and without compromising the philosophy for the sake of a good story.

The stories are used as a way in to philosophical questions about what it means to be a creature, about animal and human "consciousness", God, dignity, youth, old age, the relationship between science, philosophy and storytelling and about what it means to live an authentic individual life. A book such as this--personal recollections of family pets, family members, autobiography and serious philosophy, would have been difficult to write because of the dangers of sliding into a self-regarding, self-indulgent, sentimental mode are obvious. What makes this highly unusual book such an immensely enjoyable read is the fact that Gaita is a gifted writer, a deeply sensitive, imaginative man as well as a profound philosopher. --Larry Brown

 
Moving, Subtle Book ****
Raimond Gaita, a moral philosopher by profession, has delivered a highly literary and, at times, abstract set of reflections on animals and our relations to them. Typically, Gaita proceeds by relating a touching anecdote or quoting another writer and uses these varied inspirations to launch deep, ruminative debates on what it means to be a human being - a creature that is at home in a wide, complex web of rich, morally relevant ties which extend to and include animals.

Gaita's general philosophical stance is Wittgensteinian. That is, he inquires into the applications of our concepts, unearths unquestioned assumptions, shuns all varieties of reductionism and, in the end, offers not a concrete thesis concerning man's relation to other beasts but a series of therapeutic reflections on particular problematic cases.

While I enjoyed the refreshing nature of his approach, at times I wished he would have committed himself to a specific overarching theory or principle - something graspable. Gaita dismantles many of the wrong-headed scientific debates concerning animal consciousness admirably but the few positive proposals hidden in the text never receive the more extensive development they clearly deserve.

Still, the book is genuinely thought-provoking and has passages of great depth and beauty which the committed reader will mull over for hours on end.
 
gaita's dog eats john gray's dog ***
A clear, passionate and sometimes whimsical discussion of human relations, through the lens of our relationship with animals.

Where John Gray's Straw Dogs confronts us with the unappeasable spectre of pessimistic skepticism via our animal nature and stops there, Gaita's book takes this position as a mere starting point. HIS philosophical dog just won't lie still...

After the first few pages you might think you are merely in for a bunch of sweet homely anecdotes about Gaita and his menagerie, but things soon get weighty, with a lovely take on Wittgenstein via an account of discussions with the author's daughter, plus several inspiring adventures in skepticism.

The weaker sections of the book, for me, were (my titles) 'Literature as Lebens-Philosophy' (too vague) and 'Rock-climbing as Existential Task' (like a philosopher's contribution to a mountaineers' monthly).

Reading this definitely made me interested in investigating his other works.


Tachyos.org  |  Chronon Critical Points  |  Recent Science Book Reviews