Show Book List

Reviews from Amazon
Amazon.com (0192805991) 24 reviews
Amazon.co.uk (0192805991) 4 reviews
A selection of these reviews is given below

 

John Emsley

The elements of murder

The poisonous nature of heavy metals such as mercury, arsenic and lead is well known. In this book John Emsley examines how such elements have affected us, looking at their occurence in the environment, the danger they pose in industry and their use as medicines (where they poison the organisms which attack us). As such it is very informative, looking at the history of the elements, the symptoms they produce and their toxicity in organic and inorganic forms. But most of all it is about the use of these elements by murderers. If you enjoy a good murder story then you should certainly try this book.

I was surprised at how long it took to catch some of the murderers and I'm glad that modern procedures are much better at identifying these poisons.

I found that this book takes a bit of getting into - its a long book, and murders which would merit a few pages elsewhere get a whole chapter here. However, once you accept this then you should find it an enjoyable read.

There is also speculation on how some well know people may have been affected by these poisons. Newton probably suffered from mercury poisoning due his alchemical studies. The madness of King George could have been caused by lead in his wine, and the antimony in Mozart's medicines probably killed him.

Amazon.com info
Hardcover 436 pages  
ISBN: 0192805991
Salesrank: 265753
Weight:1.68 lbs
Published: 2005 Oxford University Press, USA
Amazon price $25.50
Marketplace:New from $3.99:Used from $3.42
Buy from Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk info
Hardcover 436 pages  
ISBN: 0192805991
Salesrank: 285615
Weight:1.68 lbs
Published: 2005 OUP Oxford
Amazon price £17.09
Marketplace:New from £5.39:Used from £4.05
Buy from Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca info
Hardcover 436 pages  
ISBN: 0192805991
Salesrank: 273205
Weight:1.68 lbs
Published: 2005 Oxford University Press
Amazon price CDN$ 25.17
Marketplace:New from CDN$ 16.83:Used from CDN$ 3.47
Buy from Amazon.ca

Product Description
Was Napoleon killed by the arsenic in his wallpaper? How did Rasputin survive cyanide poisoning? Which chemicals in our environment pose the biggest threat to our health today?
In The Elements of Murder, John Emsley offers a fascinating account of five of the most toxic elements--arsenic, antimony, lead, mercury, and thallium--describing their lethal chemical properties and highlighting their use in some of the most famous murder cases in history. Indeed, we meet in this book a who's who of heartless murderers. Mary Ann Cotton, who used arsenic to murder her mother, three husbands, a lover, eight of her own children, and seven step children, a grand total of 20 people. Michael Swango, who may have killed as many as 60 of his patients and several of his colleagues during the 20 years he practiced as a doctor and paramedic. And even Saddam Hussein, who used thallium sulfate to poison his political rivals. Emsley also shows which toxic elements may have been behind the madness of King George III (almost certainly a case of acute lead poisoning), the delusions of Isaac Newton, and the strange death of King Charles II. In addition, the book examines many modern day environmental catastrophes, including accidental mass poisoning from lead and arsenic, and the Minamata Bay disaster in Japan.
Written by a leading science writer, famous for his knowledge of the elements and their curious and colorful histories, The Elements of Murder offers an enticing combination of true crime tales and curious science that adds up to an addictive read.
 
Elements of Darkness *****
The poisonous elements spotlighted in this book--mercury, arsenic, antimony, lead, and thallium--also served as medications for most of recorded history. It is amazing what people would concoct and swallow to cure constipation, including mercury laxatives and antimony `perpetual pills' that passed through the gut and irritated it into expelling its contents. These pills could be washed off and recycled. In fact, "there are reports that such pills were highly effective and passed from generation to generation."

"The Elements of Murder" makes it clear that it was sometimes impossible to determine whether a victim was poisoned by his enemies or his doctors.

The author, John Emsley is both a chemist and an award-winning science writer. He chronicles the characteristics of each element with a magisterial British presence that eludes many American science writers, who sometimes place a heavy reliance on adjectives. Emsley goes for the telling anecdote. The insanity of men slowly poisoned by lead is revealed in a list of items they stored in a lifeboat: "button polish, silk handkerchiefs, curtain rods, and a portable writing desk." The largest mass poisoning by arsenic was actually funded by UNICEF in an effort to provide clean drinking water to the people of West Bengal, India and Bangladesh.

Although the stories of individual poisoners and their victims are interesting, the author's investigations into the wholesale slaughter of people by insidious, omnipresent elements in their environment are equally compelling. Were both the Roman AND British Empires brought low by lead?

Read "The Elements of Murder" and decide for yourself.

 
Value added online versionI *****
I love the value added online version which gave me the option to pay a nominal amount to browse the book any time online.
 
enlightening ****
this book is very enlightening. i am an author and write murder stories; so this book has been a great help to me in getting the facts straight. keep up the good work, Mr. Emsley.
mary speranza (author of POOKIE)
 
Fun history of the chemical elements used as poisons *****
I got this book on a whim after reading the back; only later did I notice it was by John Emsley, author of _Nature's Building Blocks: An A-Z Guide to the Elements_, a book I had already read and enjoyed (and reviewed here on Amazon). The books don't duplicate each other at all, as Emsley uses this one to focus on those elements that have been used as poisons. That doesn't mean all poisonous elements, since some are not practical for common use as poisons. Emsley recounts evocatively the tales of murder involving the elements that make practical poisons, explaining how the murders were uncovered through either standard or scientific means. But note the publication date; a second edition will likely add a new element, polonium, to account for the widely-publicized murder of Alexander Litvinenko in Nov. 2006.
 
science is awesome *****
I'm in the middle of this book now and can't stop blurting out random tid bits about poisonous wallpaper and large numbers of alchemists accidentally huffing themselves to death on mercury vapors. In any case this book isn't really about murder despite the title, it is simply and completely about a few periodic elements that can kill (mercury, arsenic, thallium, lead and antimony). That's it. But the author thoroughly examines each chemically (in layman's terms), historically and peppered with interesting stories. It's well organized into focused chunks for easy digestion.

I'd recommend this to somewhat morbid people with a taste for interesting non fiction or possibly true crime fans, though this isn't a true crime book per se.

I'll be re-reading this one once I get it back from the three or four people that have expressed an interest in borrowing it from me.
 
Oddly Unsatisfying ***
John Emsley is one of my favourite science writers and I came to this tome with high hopes of being thoroughly entertained, but finished it with a vague sense of disappointment

Entitled « Elements of Murder » the book actually only considers the malicious use of five _ mercury, lead, arsenic, thallium and antimony. Unhappily for Emsley (and even more unhappily for the recipient), the alleged use of polonium as a poison post dates this work, or the variety could have been improved.

The science bits of the book (how and why these things are so darned nasty) is superbly written, as are the sections of what can only be called trivia - the speculations the both Mozart and Napoleon met their ends as the result of ingesting, either by accident or design, toxic metals. Where the book fails to deliver is in the description of some famous proved cases of murder by poisoning, such as those carried out by George Chapman. Emsley is a talented science writer, not a teller of juicy scandal and by the time the last couple of murders are reached, the tales are getting a little repetitive.

Buy the book for well written popular science and you will not be disappointed: buy it for the history of crime and I think you might feel short changed.
 
Just what the Doctor ordered. *****
I really enjoyed reading this book. It struck an excellent balance between scientific insight and salacious gossip. What a combination!

I was reading this in my hospital bed needing something demanding enough to save me from terminal boredom, but that I could pick up in short bursts. Just what the Doctor ordered.
 
A Cheap 'Cut and Paste' Effort. **
The concept of the book is clever: it takes the main heavy metal elements and discusses their uses and misuses, in respect of murder.
The result, however, is disappointing. It appears to have been written across a weekend by taking a few very basis facts and then pasting in chunks of `off the shelf' (often rambling) criminal biography.
Considering Emsley is a scientist most parts of the book are so un-scientific to be exasperating. I quote just two examples: in respect of the possibility of lead ingestion being the cause of gout (in the 1800's) `there is no reason why this could (cause gout) but it does' (!). Equally the madness of King George III he attributes to lead (despite a mass of contrary research on this subject - which he fails to quote), `because he was fond of lemonade and sauerkraut' (allegedly high in lead).
Readable, but a really cheap `put-together'. Mr Emsley, please spend a little more time
 
It didn't meet my expectations. **
This book was promising. My advice would be to read the introduction which is well written and interesting and ignore the rest of it. Everything that followed the introduction was of such a poor quality that I could not believe the author of the introduction to be the same as for the main body of the book. For reasons best known to the author there were digressions into vitriolic judgements on the sexual proclivities of King Charles and some quite unsustainable remarks about Isaac Newton. What a shame! I was really looking forward to this book, and whereas the introduction had some very nicely written paragraphs the main body of the book was in ungainly prose. I didn't read much beyond the third chapter -perhaps it improved.
For something much more worthwhile read Poisons: From Hemlock to Botox and the Killer Bean of Calabar by Peter Macinnins.

Tachyos.org  |  Chronon Critical Points  |  Recent Science Book Reviews