Show Book List

Reviews from Amazon
Amazon.co.uk (1857026187) 13 reviews
A selection of these reviews is given below

 

Vilayanur Ramachandran and Sandra Blakeslee

Phantoms in the brain

Starting from the phenomenon of phantom limbs, Ramachandran looks at how the human mind responds to physical and neurological problems. He moves on through such conditions as: blindsight, neglect of one half of the body, and denial of paralysis. However his goal is wider than just describing the medical effects, he also takes the opportunity to explore the consequences for the philosophy of mind. He seems prepared to speculate more than most, but always recognises the vital importance of experimental support for ideas. If you are interested in the workings of the mind then this book will provide you with some fascinating insights

There's the risk with this sort of book that we see the patients as some sort of freak, being amused by their inability to do ordinary tasks, but Ramachandran avoids this mixing the examples with similar ones of everyday behaviour. Furthermore he shows that the wider knowledge of such conditions means a better chance of treating them. I feel that the most important part of Ramachandran's approach is his openness to new ways of testing ideas about the mind. For instance Freud's work is seen by many nowadays as a collection of untestable stories. However, Ramachandran shows that there is the possibility of finding ways of testing these ideas.

Amazon.com info
Hardcover 352 pages  
ISBN: 1857026187
Salesrank: 2407925
Weight:1.45 lbs
Published: 1998 Fourth Estate Ltd
Marketplace:New from $511.99:Used from $12.89
Buy from Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk info
Hardcover 352 pages  
ISBN: 1857026187
Salesrank: 682735
Weight:1.45 lbs
Published: 1998 Fourth Estate
Marketplace:New from £6.00:Used from £5.69
Buy from Amazon.co.uk






Product Description
This series of case histories, introduces strange and unexplored mental worlds. The author's research has discovered that the brain is continually organizing itself in response to change. A man loses his arm in a motorcycle accident yet he continues to feel a phantom arm.
 
Never thought i'd understand neuroscience! ****
A really interesting book with some great real life stories to frame Ramachandrans research and discussions. It is made really easy to understand without neglecting some real scientific jargon (just explained in a way that makes it make sense). I struggled to get to grips with the last chapter, otherwise it would have got 5 stars.
But I liked also that if you wanted to research areas further, the reference list and notes were included, which rarely are, a great added bonus!
 
Strong, but could be shorter. ***
VS Ramachandran is a highly respected neurologist whose body of research is vast. This book tries to cover the majority of it, with some metaphysics and psychology added as well. Although I very much enjoyed the initial chapters of the book (the ones dealing with neurological patients and understanding how us 'normal' people function by understanding the dysfunction in their conditions) towards the end I felt that Ramachandran wavered from the initial excitement to a more mellow, hazy abstraction on matters of philosophy.

Ramachandran understands the implications of all of his research in understanding how consciousness manifests itself. However, he tries too hard to form a grand unified 'neuroscientific metaphysics.'He also tries to use neurological means to substantiate personal beliefs and much of his hypotheses (he does emphasize the speculative nature of his theories, one must say) are currently tenuous. I suspect that he perhaps reduced the level of complexity of many of his theories to satisfy the layman and this is unfortunate if true.

To summarise, there are numerous positive points about this book e.g. the brilliant analysis of phantom limbs and the pratical solutions associated with it, the incredibly erudite and interesting exploration of neurological deficits in patients and therefore the improvement in understanding how our brains work and finally the substantial notes section in the back of the book for an interested reader. I must also say that the writing style is excellent, both engaging and humorous. However, I feel that Ramachandran has tried to extend his theories too far in the latter section of the book. They seem highly speculative and beyond the realm of conventional science at the moment.

Therefore, I reccommend that any individual may buy this to savour those early chapters however be wary of the latter three or four chapters.
 
Not Rigorous but a lot of FUN! ****
Excellent read on neurology (understood by exploring pathology), very entertaining. At times quite speculative and Ramachandran does warn that results are anecdotal/preliminary and implications far from conclusive but generally it is easy to spot that. It's science mixed with insight and altogether just a fun read. But far from rigorous for the more science minded...
 
Phantoms in the Brain ****
`Phantoms in the Brain' is a highly accessible look at how the brain works via the study of various neurological disorders. It looks at topics such as phantom limbs, limb neglect, visual disorders, underlying consciousness and way more besides. The writing style is extremely easy to read and completely engaging. The author uses numerous anecdotes and fascinating case studies to illustrate various points and you could quite easily read this book for these insightful glimpses into the human mind alone, the fact that it is backed up by sound science and imparts knowledge is a happy bonus in some respects. There are some illustrations used throughout to clarify particular points and there are even some minor experiments you can try on yourself to see how certain aspects of your brain work. If the human brain has even remotely interested you, or if you're a fan of popular science books, then I'd suggest you read this book. It is clear to read, engaging and makes for fascinating reading. Well worth a look.

Dedicated to Stephen A. Haines whose reviews inspired me to read some amazing science books and who will be greatly missed.
 
Would benefit from being shorter ***
V. interesting laymans guide to how and why you do the things you do. Particularly enjoyed the self test activities. Found myself scanning some of the later chapters which got a bit too technical - if the book was 100 pages shorter none of the pleasure would have been lost for the average reader.

Tachyos.org  |  Chronon Critical Points  |  Recent Science Book Reviews