Show Book List

Reviews from Amazon
Amazon.com (1591022851) 3 reviews
A selection of these reviews is given below

Reviews elsewhere on the web:
Peter T. Landsberg
David Ludden

Moti Ben-Ari

Just a theory

When someone criticises part of science for being 'Just a theory' you know that that person really has very little idea what scientists really do. In Just a theory : exploring the nature of science Moti Ben-Ari takes a look at such misunderstandings, and more generally at the way science works. There's a chapter on the way scientists use words and how the this may conflict with everyday usage. Ben-Ari also discusses the philosophy of science, such as Popper's falsificationism, whether Kuhn's paradigms are an accurate description of what goes on, and what distinguishes real science from pseudoscience.

Ben-Ari examines the ideas from the sociology of science, and at how these all too easily descend into the nonsense of postmodernism. There is then a look at the relationship between religion and science followed by a chapter on the nature of reductionism. The last few chapters are a bit less argumentative, dealing with statistics, how logic and mathematics are used in science and a chapter on the Wegener's ideas on continental drift, and how they were originally laughed at. The final chapter is about the future of science - Ben-Ari predicts there won't be any more scientific revolutions, which seems a bit tame for my liking. Overall the book is clearly written and easy to read, and just what you need if you want to argue with the muddled ideas about science which some people have.

Amazon.com info
Paperback 237 pages  
ISBN: 1591022851
Salesrank: 176420
Weight:0.84 lbs
Published: 2005 Prometheus Books
Amazon price $21.98
Marketplace:New from $10.00:Used from $4.50
Buy from Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk info
Paperback 237 pages  
ISBN: 1591022851
Salesrank: 1499967
Weight:0.84 lbs
Published: 2005 Prometheus Books
Amazon price £16.99
Marketplace:New from £9.09:Used from £7.68
Buy from Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca info
Paperback 237 pages  
ISBN: 1591022851
Salesrank: 757990
Weight:0.84 lbs
Published: 2005 PROMETHEUS BOOKS
Amazon price CDN$ 17.00
Marketplace:New from CDN$ 15.06:Used from CDN$ 12.54
Buy from Amazon.ca






Product Description
Some people claim that evolution is "just a theory". Do you know what a scientific theory really is? Just a theory is an overview of the modern concepts of science. A clear understanding of the nature of science will enable you to distinguish science from pseudoscience (which illegitimately wraps itself in the mantle of science), and real social issues in science from the caricatures portrayed in postmodernist critiques.

Prof. Ben-Ari’s style is light (even humorous) and easy to read, bringing the latest concepts of science to the general reader. Of particular interest is his analysis of the terminology of science (fact, law, proof, theory) in relation to the colloquial meaning of these terms.

Between chapters are biographical vignettes of scientists—both familiar and unfamiliar—showing their common commitment to the enterprise of science, together with a diversity of backgrounds and personalities.

This accessible, informative, and comprehensive work will give lay readers a good grasp of real science.

 
Thought-provoking and very readable ****
A very good book, in most ways. It covers some familiar ground, but generally with a fresh perspective. One limitation is that it really does stick to the goal of answering that tiresome, bone-headed criticism of evolution as being "just a theory." Thus, much space is devoted to hammering home the definition of the word "theory." But this explanation does range through many interesting examples, and is always readable.

Where I part company with the author is in his closing statements, to the effect that most of what there is to be discovered has already been discovered. (I paraphrase, badly.) I believe that Ben-Ari underestimates the quantity of what we do not yet know, as well as the potential impact of numerous breakthroughs that can already be foreseen. Of course, that's all speculation, and Ben-Ari's take is at least stimulating.

In short, a quick, entertaining, worthwhile read.
 
An Easy and Enjoyable Introduction to Philosophy of Science *****
The majority of books on philosophy of science are written by philosophers, and they tend to get into a lot of hair splitting, often with drawn out arguments and counterarguments. While this rigor is necessary to convey the full subleties and complexities of the subject, it can also test a reader's patience, obscure key points, and become so overwhelming for beginners that many will abandon the subject as too muddled or too useless (or both!).

Ben-Ari's book is refreshing in that it provides an introduction to philosophy of science which cuts to the chase and is easy and enjoyable to read, and therefore ideal for beginners. A further plus is that the author is a computer scientist with an impressive grasp of a diverse range of sciences, and the illustrative examples in the book are correspondingly diverse.

Ben-Ari has an evident pro-science bias, and thus tends to somewhat downplay arguments which reveal the limitations and confusions of science, but I still think that his presentation is balanced enough to make this book an excellent introduction to the subject.

Readers who already have some background in philosophy of science should find the book to be a quick and entertaining review of the subject, but will probably finish the book with the thought "I already knew all of this, and need to read something more challenging and advanced."

Nonetheless, this an excellent book for what it aims to do, and is written with admirable clarity and conciseness.
 
Enjoyable and informative ****
Ben-Ari has written a highly enjoyable book about the nature of science that reads quickly and easily. I strongly recommend this book for anyone involved with teaching science (that may be a professor, secondary, or elementary school teacher). The author takes the best, most sober points from philosophers, historians, and sociologists of science and demonstrates the implications these works have for preparing a scientifically literate public. He clarifies troublesome definitions such as "theory" "fact" "proof" and "hypothesis". His insights on falsification and the need for an understanding of statistics are dead-on. I am using this book in the post-secondary courses I teach.
Why only four stars? First, in his scientists' vignettes (where he uses biographical information on a scientist to illustrate a nature-of-science-point) are a rather homogenous bunch, for true excellence I would have to see more diverse group of scientists discussed. Secondly, his understanding of science as a discourse is somewhat impoverished, and I would say that his treatment of the topic isn't completely fair.
But- this should not take away from a strong recommendation. Great book!

Tachyos.org  |  Chronon Critical Points  |  Recent Science Book Reviews